The only way out of populism is through it
The lesson of Britain and America is that bad ideas have to be tested to destruction
Janan Ganesh
First in, first out.
That is how it works.
The past decade of illiberal politics began in Britain and America, which voted for Brexit and Donald Trump within months of each other.
Now, both countries can see a path to, if not the status quo ante, then relative calm.
Nigel Farage’s Reform UK is down to third in the polls.
The US president is a reduced figure.
The first nations to catch the fever might be the first to shake it off.
Moderates around the world should take some comfort from the Anglo-American experience, but some dread too.
There is one way out of populism, it seems.
The movement and its ideas have to be tried and seen to fail.
Defeating it is as doable and as horrible as that.
What does not work?
Campaigning harder against populists, for one thing.
There are forensic and impassioned arguments against Marine Le Pen. France’s far-right presidential favourite still polls twice or more than centre-ground candidates.
Governing better is no answer either.
When Trump was first elected, US inflation was below 2 per cent.
Barack Obama would have had a decent chance of a third term.
When Britain voted to Leave, the prime minister David Cameron had been re-elected 13 months earlier with an increased number of MPs.
Misgovernment did not create populism.
Sublime government, while desirable on its own terms, will not beat it.
No, voters are just drawn to the flame, and will be until they’re burnt.
You must conclude that, in France, the political centre will never revive until the alternative to it is at last tested in office.
At that point, Le Pen can no longer be a Professional Againster, as an exasperated studio boss once called James Cagney.
She would have to make tax-and-spend decisions, and be correspondingly tainted.
No western nation has flirted more with the hard right without giving it power.
To Le Pen, that is a frustration — and a gift.
This is the choice for democracies.
Is it better to have a huge populist opposition, fouling the atmosphere on an indefinite basis, or populists in office, doing concrete harm for a while before fading?
Either answer is fair.
France might be a tinderbox, decade after decade, but it is still inside its own continent’s €18tn single market.
Britain, having fallen for populism once, and fallen big, is not.
Likewise, the Maga era might turn out to be a phase, but the doubt it has cast on America’s international trustworthiness is lasting.
Isn’t it better to be Germany, where the hard right is strong but out of federal power?
A lot can go wrong in a “phase”.
Whichever is preferable — the thorn in the side, or the brief anguish of pulling it out — this seems to be the trade-off.
There is no way out of populism, except through it.
Brazil, the other encouraging case study of the year for liberals, rejected Bolsonaro Jr.
It might not have done so had it not experienced the old man.
In 2016, I thought that British and American voters had done the equivalent of donating their bodies to medical science.
The world would see their radical choices go wrong, and refuse to make similar ones at home.
It turns out that people have to experience things for themselves.
To be clear, the experience of populism does not have to be disastrous to put people off.
(The US has spent six years under Trump without falling apart.)
It just needs to be disappointing.
The goal is to make voters see these rebel movements as normal, flawed parties: to judge them on the same terms as the establishment, which has a governing record to defend.
Such is Farage’s fate.
Just a quarter of Britain has a favourable view of him.
This is mid-parliament, remember, when the opposition receives the benefit of the doubt.
It is not the latest financial scandal that explains his malaise.
His ratings were awful before.
It is more that, for voters, he is not the “opposition” at all.
He is co-responsible for Brexit, the governing idea of the past decade.
His fingerprints are all over the status quo.
To invert the old line, he is in power but not in office.
His one big idea, his life’s work, was tried and seen to fail.
If my anti-populist strategy is “Give them enough rope”, what might be said against it?
For one thing, some countries are able to defeat these parties without testing them to destruction in office.
However, the examples always centre on Denmark for a reason: there is not an endless number of other ones.
And even in Denmark, the far right had some of its policies implemented in return for supporting a minority coalition government.
Another riposte to me is that populists, once in power, will rig things to stay there.
That fear was expressed a lot a decade ago.
It seems overdone now.
January 6 2021, when the US failed to have a peaceful transfer of power, was a historic disgrace.
But there was never much chance of Trump hanging on.
What remains, then, is the principled argument.
If a political movement is bad for your country, fight it at every turn: intellectually, organisationally.
It is too clever by half to do anything else.
There is nobility in this viewpoint.
I just wonder about the strategic judgment.
We will probably never know which US officer, if any, said after the Battle of Ben Tre during the Vietnam war, “It became necessary to destroy the town to save it.”
But the paradox is often a useful one in politics.
Britain is only stabilising now because it suffered for a decade.
There are countries near at hand that have all the education ahead of them.

0 comments:
Publicar un comentario